Make-to-Order Production Planning for Small Businesses
Make to order workflows need different approaches when it comes to production planning - we show you how to design a production process to maximise your small business success.
For small DTC manufacturing companies, it’s important to deliver high-quality products on time to your customers.
But constantly hitting both — high quality and on-time delivery — is genuinely hard, especially when every order is different. That’s the reality of make-to-order production.
MTO is a production strategy where goods are manufactured only after a customer places an order. No speculative stock. No batches sitting in boxes waiting to be claimed. Just production that starts when a sale is confirmed.
For most small makers, MTO is the default — especially in the early years. You’re not producing 200 units ahead of demand; you’re making 3–5 items per week as orders arrive. The planning challenge grows as volume does: what works fine at 10 orders a month breaks down at 50.
In this post, we’ll cover what MTO production planning actually looks like in practice, how it works specifically for Etsy and Shopify sellers, and what you need to keep it running without dropping the ball on a single order.
Ensure your production planning and scheduling is on point!
Try Craftybase - the inventory and manufacturing solution for DTC sellers. Track raw materials and product stock levels (in real time!), COGS, shop floor assignment and much more.
It's your new production central.
What is production planning?
Production planning is the process of mapping out how a product will be manufactured — what materials you need, who does the work, in what order, and by when.
It covers everything from procurement of raw materials through to final delivery. Done well, it keeps your resources optimised, your costs under control, and your customers happy.
Read more: The Ultimate Guide to Production Planning & Scheduling
The role of Make to Order (MTO) in production planning
Traditionally, manufacturing companies have relied on Make to Stock (MTS) production — goods are produced and stocked in anticipation of demand. It’s cost-effective when you can predict what will sell, because it allows for mass production and bulk purchasing of raw materials.
The downside? If the products don’t sell as expected, you end up with overproduction, excess inventory, and tied-up capital sitting on shelves. For a small maker, even $500 in unsold finished goods can cause a genuine cash flow problem if you need to restock materials for new orders.
MTO flips this around. Products are only manufactured once a customer places an order. The “just in time” approach eliminates the need to hold finished goods, which reduces inventory costs and minimises waste. For small makers with limited storage and cash flow, that’s a meaningful advantage.
The trade-off is complexity. MTO requires tighter coordination between your sales channel, your materials stock, and your production capacity — because there’s no buffer stock to fall back on.
Make-to-order planning for Etsy and Shopify sellers
Most MTO content is written for factory-floor manufacturers. But if you’re running an Etsy shop or a Shopify store, the practical reality looks quite different.
On Etsy, you’re often managing custom orders, variations, and personalisation requests alongside standard listings. When a customer orders a custom jewellery piece or a hand-stamped leather wallet, your production window starts the moment you accept the order. Etsy’s 3–5 day processing time expectations mean you need a clear system to know exactly which materials you have on hand before confirming.
A few things that matter specifically for Etsy MTO sellers:
- Accurate processing times. Setting your processing time conservatively in your listing is better than rushing a job and shipping something that’s not your best work. A useful starting point: track your last 10 orders and calculate your actual average fulfilment time, then add 20% as a buffer. Craftybase’s production scheduling tools help you set realistic windows based on your current queue.
- Material availability at order time. Etsy doesn’t connect to your materials inventory — you need to check manually, or use a tool that tracks stock in real time. Running out of a specific leather colour or stone mid-fulfilment damages your shop’s completion rate.
- Clear order notes and customisation tracking. Custom orders generate a lot of back-and-forth. Keep a single place to track the customer specification, not a mix of Etsy messages and sticky notes.
On Shopify, the setup is different. You’re typically running your own store with more control over order management, but you still need the MTO discipline — especially if your products are made-to-order but not custom. Items like hand-poured candles, soap bars, and food-safe resin pieces are often made fresh per order, even if there’s no personalisation involved.
For Shopify sellers:
- Link your production to your inventory system. When an order comes in, your material levels should update automatically. If they don’t, you’re tracking things twice (or not at all).
- Build a production queue. Shopify gives you the order; you still need to decide the sequence in which orders get made. Prioritise by due date, material readiness, or batch efficiency — but have a system.
- Watch your product cost as you scale. MTO is manageable at low volume. As order frequency grows, the cost of each individual run (especially setup time) adds up. Knowing your COGS per order helps you spot the point where batching makes more sense.
How to implement a make-to-order production planning strategy
Understand your customers’ needs
To incorporate MTO production planning, you need to know your customers’ requirements thoroughly — product specifications, order volume, delivery deadlines, and any customisation details.
The more clearly you understand what each order involves before you confirm it, the more accurately you can plan. Delays and errors almost always trace back to unclear requirements that only became apparent mid-production.
Develop a solid production plan
Once you understand the order requirements, build a production plan that includes raw material procurement, inventory management, production scheduling, labour allocation, quality control, and delivery logistics.
The plan should be flexible enough to handle changes in customer specifications or unexpected disruptions — a material delayed by a supplier, an order that turns out more complex than expected.
It should also account for your actual capacity: how many hours you can produce per day, and how many orders can run concurrently without cutting corners. A useful rule of thumb: never schedule more than 80% of your available production hours. That 20% buffer absorbs the delays that will inevitably come.
Use technology to keep your workflow on track
To keep MTO production planning under control, you need your tools talking to each other. A production scheduling software system can automate parts of the process, track the progress of individual orders, and surface the data you need without manual chasing.
Good technology reduces lead times, cuts overhead, and gives you an accurate picture of where each order sits in your production pipeline.
Read more: Production Planning Tools to Take Your Small Business to the Next Level
Collaborate with suppliers and partners
Reliable supplier relationships become critical in MTO workflows. Because you’re not holding buffer stock, a late delivery from a supplier can directly delay a customer order with no fallback.
Build relationships with backup suppliers for key materials, and keep your lead times current. If a supplier’s lead time changes, your production estimates need to update with it.
Monitor, evaluate and improve your processes
Track your production KPIs — order fulfilment rates, delivery times, error rates, and production costs. Analyse the data to find where orders consistently slow down or go sideways.
Talk to customers too. Their experience of your fulfilment process is a useful signal for what’s working and what isn’t.
A real-world MTO walkthrough: handmade soy candles on Etsy
Let’s make this concrete. Say you’re running an Etsy shop selling handmade soy candles. You don’t batch produce — each order is made fresh.
The order lands. A customer buys two 200g amber jar candles with custom fragrance (lavender + vanilla blend), with a requested ship date in five days.
Check material availability. Before confirming the processing time, you check your stock: soy wax (need 450g, have 2kg ✓), amber jars (need 2, have 8 ✓), lavender fragrance oil (need 25ml, have 18ml ✗). You’re short on lavender oil.
Immediate sourcing decision. You either message the customer to discuss an alternative fragrance, or place an express order for lavender oil and adjust the ship date. The key point: you caught this before confirming, not on day four of a five-day window.
Schedule the production run. With materials confirmed, you slot the order into your production queue. You’re making three other orders this week, so you batch the pour day — you’ll produce all candle orders on Wednesday, label Thursday, ship Friday.
Track the batch. During production, you note how much wax, oil, and jars were consumed. Your material stock updates accordingly.
Fulfil and follow up. The candles ship on Friday. Your inventory reflects the consumed materials. You have an accurate view of your remaining stock for the next order.
This process works because each step connects to the next. The failure point for most small makers is the material check step — because their stock isn’t tracked in real time, they’re guessing.
How Craftybase can help make-to-order manufacturers
Craftybase is production planning software designed for small batch and made-to-order DTC businesses.
With features including order tracking, material purchasing, and production scheduling, Craftybase brings your MTO workflow into one place. When an order comes in, you can check material availability, schedule production, track the run, and update your inventory — all without switching between spreadsheets, Etsy messages, and handwritten notes.
Real-time data analytics let you monitor your KPIs and make informed decisions as you scale.
Start your free 14-day trial and see if Craftybase’s production planning features fit how you work.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is make-to-order production planning?
Make-to-order (MTO) production planning is the process of organising and scheduling manufacturing activity that only begins when a confirmed customer order is received. Unlike make-to-stock, where goods are produced in advance, MTO means nothing gets made until there's a paying customer. For small makers, this eliminates the risk of unsold inventory but requires tight coordination between your order queue, material stock, and production capacity.
What's the difference between make-to-order and make-to-stock?
Make-to-stock (MTS) means you produce goods in advance and hold them as finished inventory, ready to ship when an order comes in. Make-to-order (MTO) means production only starts once a customer places and confirms an order. MTS suits products with predictable, stable demand. MTO suits custom, personalised, or low-volume products where holding finished stock would tie up cash and storage. Many Etsy and Shopify sellers use MTO even for non-custom items simply because it's more cash-efficient at small scale.
How do I set realistic processing times for make-to-order Etsy listings?
Start with your actual production time for one unit, then add your average queue backlog. If it takes you two hours to make one item and you typically have three other orders in progress, your minimum processing time should account for all of that — not just the production time alone. Build in a buffer for material sourcing delays, especially for custom materials. Setting conservative processing times and meeting them consistently builds better reviews than ambitious times you occasionally miss.
Does Craftybase support make-to-order workflows?
Yes — Craftybase is specifically designed for small batch and make-to-order DTC sellers. It connects to Etsy and Shopify so orders sync automatically, tracks your raw material stock in real time, and lets you record material consumption against each manufacturing run. When an order comes in, you can check whether you have enough materials to fulfil it before committing to a ship date. Craftybase also generates COGS reports per order, which is useful for understanding whether your MTO pricing is actually profitable.
What are the biggest mistakes make-to-order sellers make with production planning?
The most common mistakes are: (1) not checking material availability before confirming an order — this leads to late fulfilments or awkward customer conversations mid-production; (2) underestimating queue depth — production time estimates that ignore other orders in progress lead to missed ship dates; (3) not tracking material consumption — without recording what each order uses, your inventory data drifts and the next material check becomes unreliable; and (4) pricing without real COGS data — in MTO workflows, each order's true cost includes material, time, and packaging. Guessing leads to underpricing.
